Some projects are bigger than a single home.
They carry history, responsibility, and the need to get things done the right way. This was the case for a large hunting and fishing lodge located in Dingmans Ferry, Pennsylvania a well-known, historic structure in the area that was due for another full roof replacement. The lodge invited several roofing contractors to bid on the project, including Overmyer Roofing.
From the very beginning, it was clear this would not be a standard residential roofing job.
Doing What’s Right — Even Before Being Chosen
Because this building is a multi-owner property, the warranty options available are very different from those of a single-family residence. During our initial conversations, we were the only contractor to bring this up explaining how manufacturer warranties apply differently and what needed to be structured correctly to ensure the property was truly protected long-term. We didn’t just explain this to the lodge members we also shared this information openly so that any contractor bidding the project would have the opportunity to submit a proposal that met the correct requirements.
That transparency mattered.
After extensive evaluations, design discussions, and careful review of the roof’s unique structure, Overmyer Roofing was selected for the project for knowledge, honesty, and
accountability.
Rebuilding From the Deck Up
Due to the age of the building, the project required a complete tear-off of all existing roofing materials. Once removed, the original roof deck was exposed old plank board decking with large gaps between boards, which is not suitable for modern roofing system installation.
To ensure the new roof would perform properly, we installed new plywood sheathing across the entire roof surface, creating a solid, code-compliant foundation.
During this phase, lodge members also requested the removal of a dormer on the front roof slope. We carefully removed the structure, framed it out, and seamlessly tied it back into the roof system.
As access to the eaves was gained, additional issues were uncovered:
● Broken rafter tails
● Rotted fascia boards
● Heavy debris buildup restricting attic airflow
Rather than covering these issues, we addressed them head-on. We rebuilt the eaves, installed new vented vinyl soffit for proper intake ventilation, and finished the perimeter with custom-bent aluminum fascia.
Complete Water Management — Roof to Ground
To further protect the structure, we installed 6-inch commercial-style aluminum gutters designed to handle higher roof volumes and heavy rainfall. These were paired with professional-grade gutter protection, reducing debris buildup and helping ensure consistent water flow away from the building year-round.
This system adds another critical layer of defense especially important for a large roof structure surrounded by trees and exposed to seasonal weather.
A Roof Built to Perform for Decades
With the structure corrected and properly prepared, we installed a CertainTeed Landmark Pro Five-Star roofing system, complete with:
● Proper soffit intake ventilation
● Continuous ridge vent exhaust
● Manufacturer-approved materials throughout
The result is a fully integrated roofing and drainage system designed to perform, breathe, and protect this historic lodge for many years to come.
Despite the scale and complexity of the project, the entire installation was completed in approximately six days, thanks to efficient material coordination from our vendors and the
execution of our highly trained crew.
Experience, Integrity, and Long-Term Protection
Large, multi-owner properties require more than just labor they require planning, communication, and an understanding of what’s at stake. This project wasn’t just about installing shingles it was about protecting a landmark and the people who rely on it.
At Overmyer Roofing, we bring the same level of care, transparency, and craftsmanship to every project whether it’s a single-family home or a historic lodge. When the details matter and the stakes are high, we’re proud to be the contractor trusted to get it right.
